Home > Dating > Should You Date Someone Who Has Different Religious Beliefs?

Should You Date Someone Who Has Different Religious Beliefs?

What if you’re Catholic and her boyfriend is Muslim – should you date a guy who follows a different religion? Interfaith relationships (and marriages) can be strong and happy, but they’re also a lot of work.

Before I give you a few things to think about, I want to give you something to ponder:

“I believe in God, but not as one thing, not as an old man in the sky. I believe that what people call God is something in all of us. I believe that what Jesus and Mohammed and Buddha and all the rest said was right. It’s just that the translations have gone wrong.” – John Lennon.

The first thing you need to do is figure out whether you’re spiritual, or religious, or both. John Lennon was spiritual. I am both spiritual and religious (I follow the Christian faith as my religion, but I am always trying to build a deeper, more spiritual, more meaningful relationship with God).

If you’re serious about dating someone of a different religion, read Mixed Matches: How to Create Successful Interracial, Interethnic, and Interfaith Relationships. You may not be ready for marriage right now, but this book will help you prepare for anything.

Should You Date Someone Who Has Different Religious Beliefs?

The most important thing is to talk to your partner about your spirituality or religion. If you can’t show him or her this article, then you probably shouldn’t be dating (or marrying).

Decide how important spirituality is to you

Is your religion or spirituality an important part of your life? What do you “get” out of being a spiritual person? Do you like going to church, mosque, synagogue, or the temple every week? Would you miss your connection with God or Allah if it were gone?

If you continue to date or even marry someone of a different religion, chances are you will be drawn away from your faith. I know interfaith marriages and relationships are possible and can even be good, but they won’t create a stronger bond between you and your Creator.

I believe that if you hook up with someone who doesn’t have the same religious beliefs, then you will start to lose your connection with your faith.

Talk to your friends, family, and spiritual mentors

While I don’t think you should do everything people say, I think it’s important to listen to your loved ones. Do they support your relationship? They want the best for you. They love and care for you. They aren’t thinking with their sexy parts (like you are) and they are more objective than you are.

If your friends and family aren’t supportive of this relationship, then you need to give it more thought. Listen to their reasoning. Try not to get defensive or hurt; remember that they want the best for you.

Talk to your partner about your faith

I’m matched with a Little Sister through Big Sisters/Big Brothers. She’s Muslim, and I’m Christian.

dating a guy with different religious beliefs

Should You Date Someone Who Has Different Religious Beliefs? (image by AuntOwee, flickr)

We have a fantastic relationship – I love that girl! One of the reasons we get along so well is because we talk about our faiths all the time. She tells me how the Muslim religion works, and I tell her about Christianity. We aren’t trying to “convert” each other; we’re just having good philosophical and religious conversations.

But, I’m not dating this girl, thinking about marrying her, or planning to raise kids with her. That’s the difference between having friends of different religions versus having an interfaith marriage. Marriage is complicated and can be a lot of hard work…and marrying someone of a different religion makes things more difficult.

If you can’t talk to your partner about your faith now, then you won’t be able to talk in the future. Start opening up those discussions now.

Expect backlash from your families

If your parents have a strong religious faith, then they will be disappointed or even devastated that you’re dating someone who doesn’t believe. Don’t try to convince your parents or loved ones that you’re doing the right thing, because you’ll fail. Instead, accept their disappointment. Be honest with them. Try not to argue with them, because it’s a losing battle.

Here’s an article that will help you and your partner cope with family problems: When Your Boyfriend’s Family is Ruining Your Relationship.

Also, remember that if you marry someone outside your religion, you’ll have to decide how to raise your kids.

Don’t expect your partner to convert to your religion

Never date or marry someone with the hope or expectation that he or she will change. If you’re dating someone with different religious beliefs, you can expect him or her to stay the same.

It’s not likely that you’ll convert your partner to your faith. On the contrary, it’s far more likely that your partner will weaken your spiritual connection to God. You have to love and accept who your partner is without trying to change him.

When you’re dating someone with different religious beliefs, you need to be firm, kind, gentle, and honest with yourself and others. Try to hold on to your faith and stay true to who you are.

If you think an interfaith relationship isn’t right for you, read How to Let Go of Someone You Love.

Is your relationship in trouble? Get 7 Steps to Fixing Your Marriage from relationship coach Mort Fertel. It's free and helpful, no strings attached.

Need encouragement? Sign up for my weekly "Echoes of Joy" email - it's free, short, and energizing. Like me!


4 thoughts on “Should You Date Someone Who Has Different Religious Beliefs?”

  1. Dear Rosy,

    If I was a writer who gave relationship advice to Christian women, I’d say “Move on, Rosy girl! This guy you’re dating will crush you, tamp your spirit, and lead you away from God. If you keep this relationship going, you will regret it. Your boyfriend won’t change, and you will be constantly pulled between your relationship with him and God.”

    I’d give you that advice because of what you said:

    – You’re scared
    – Your boyfriend isn’t encouraging your to strengthen your religious beliefs or faith in God
    – Your boyfriend is threatened by your faith
    – You didn’t mention how you feel about your boyfriend

    I had so much to say, I wrote a whole article for you!

    What You Need to Know About Dating Outside Your Faith

    If you asked Jesus about your relationship, what would he say? What is God telling you about your relationship? I believe God loves you deeply – and He loves your boyfriend, too. But that doesn’t mean you’re meant to be yoked together….

    I hope you read the article I wrote, and I welcome your thoughts.

    Blessings, hugs, God’s love to you,

  2. I’ve been dating this guy about a year and a couple of months. He claims to be catholic and I’m scared because I am a christian. We have talked about marriage and moving in at are own place. But he believes that I am wrong for putting god before him! I told him I would put him first before anyone I will never give my soul up for him or anyone. He thinks I’m wrong and that he’s not willing to marry me because of what I said. Should I keep this relationship going? Or should I move on?

  3. Thanks for your comment, Lisa. I agree that dating or marrying someone outside your religion will weaken your faith.

    Plus, a common belief system is one of the best ways to build a healthy, happy marriage! Praying together, going to church or synagogue together, serving God together makes you more united as a couple.

    I really think that people can’t see God unless God reveals Himself to them. Your husband sounds like a good example of this. He couldn’t see that Jesus saved his life…maybe because for some reason God is hiding Himself. I don’t understand it, but wonder about it often!

  4. This is very thoughtful and well written. I had to divorce my ex because I realized I needed more religion and prayer in my life. The Bible says: “Do not be yoked to non-believers.” The reason for that is, as you said, you will be led astray from God. The Lord wants to have a strong relationship with everyone. Don’t waste your time trying to change anybody. I used to pray that my ex would see the light that the Lord has brought into my life. He just refused to. It was all the more strange because he was saved from certain death by Jesus. Some people wouldn’t know divine intervention if it conked them on the head. Don’t waste your time dating or marrying anyone because if you are spiritual or religious, you’ll only have heartache.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *